Now to the catch lights.
What follows is highly esoteric and far beyond the scope of all but a few photographers doing headshotscand wanting to add that extra subtle but effective sparkle.
Now tobyour headshots: In many cases they are subtle and do not draw attention except that they “work”. The lady in purple, if I was asked, I might tone down. But then if she plays a certain “character” in the theater, it could be perfect.
In general, (as a rule of thumb), not from any greater authority than my own judgement, I have found the following is best practice for most artistic alterations for exhibition:-
Of course make each change on a new layer........ the S-curve, degree of sharpening, brightness of the teeth, “just right”. Then put this picture aside for anything else like dinner, your workout, or another day.
When you pickup again, aim to decrease the percent of that effect by 30% to 90%, seeing how far you can remove it and still achieve the emotion and significance you want. It’s alwayscamazing to me, how much one can revert and still maintain the genuine feelings that you had workedcso hard to create the first time.
With catch lights, much less is more, unless it is a part of the “character”. Only clowns actually need red noses!
I prefer catchlights that one can read and discover more secrets, like reflections of bright windows, or even the photographer by his/her 8 ft octadome!
Still, solid catchlights certainly work. I have seen them used successfully as one of the uniting common marks of someone’s photographic “Style” in a major exhibition, all with the same recognizable lighting and “look”.
I would look to decreasing the intensity of catchlights as one increased actad the brightness of whites of the eyes and teeth. That way the catchlights seem appropriate to thecentire creation.