Asher asked me to provide a quick intro to LAB, since I seem to be referring to it a lot.
My knowledge of the LAB workspace comes from Dan Margulis. If you are at all interested in LAB, I urge you to buy his book
Photoshop LAB Color: The Canyon Conundrum and Other Adventures in the Most Powerful Colorspace [Paperback]. Please note that I have embedded my Amazon affiliate link in referencing Dan's book.
LAB is just another colorspace, one that I find very useful for a number of reasons. One of those reasons is ~quickly~ analyzing an image. When I have an image, I quickly scan the image in LAB looking for things that are wrong. Then I can decide if I want to fix them (often in rgb colorspace) or just accept that they are wrong. Or, I can be "artistic" and make them more wrong. The key point being that I know where I am starting from.
In LAB:
- L - Lightness 0 dark and 128 bright
- A - Magenta/Green (128 all magenta, -127 all green)
- B - Yellow/Blue (128 all yellow, -127 all blue)
Magenta and Yellow are both warm colors. And they are both positive. Many things in nature are warm. In Dan Margulis's classes, he teaches his students the following:
NEUTRALS
A and B both zero. If not exactly zero, negative numbers are cold (green/blue) and positive numbers warm (magenta/yellow).
FACES
A and B both positive. With the exception of small children and light-skinned Caucasians, the A is rarely significantly higher than the B. Asians, Hispanics, and dark-skinned Caucasians generally have B significantly higher than A.
NATURAL GREENERY
A negative, B positive. The B is almost always farther away from zero than the A, usually falling within 1.5-2.5 times the absolute value of the A.
SKIES
B is negative. A is near zero, meaning neither magenta nor green. Typically the A is slightly negative, but occasionally it is slightly positive. The B value cannot be predicted, but the A generally falls between -5 and +2.
So when looking at some of the posted images in this thread, I quickly scanned them looking at the LAB values. If I saw a negative value on the model (skin, eyes, hair), I knew something was amiss. Hair can be tricky as women often dye their hair. And then, it can be anything. However, natural hair is warm--that is, positive in the A and B channels.
If you look at my readouts in prior posts, you'll note that my right hand side readout shows LAB. It always does, even if I am in rgb colorspace. I find looking at LAB values very handy to spot errors quickly.
From my limited exposure (pun intended) to photography, I have found whites and blacks difficult. Because they are neutral, it doesn't take much to throw them off color. That is, a white top or black dress can easily appear cold (hint of green, blue, or both). Even worse, some part of the clothing might be slightly warm and other parts slightly cold. You have to decide what is acceptable.
Another thing I have learned from my limited exposure is that eye whites are tricky. As you've seen from my posts, I love color, lots of color. I often make aggressive moves to make my stuff overly colorful. If the eye whites are off, they become way off with my aggressive moves. So I usually make my eye whites neutral before I begin my aggressive moves. My aggressive moves move in proportion the color is away from neutral. Stated differently, neutral colors are unaffected by my aggressive moves, colorful colors are made more colorful.
In reality, eye whites are not truly neutral. According to Gry Garness (see
CS4 Digital Retouching For Fashion Beauty And Portrait Photography - no affiliate link) on pages 159:
Put the cursor on the clearest whites of the eyes read the INFO panel. Are the RGB numbers near equal? For an adult, the numbers should be approximately: Red as the highest number, with Green 2-3 points lower, and Blue 2-3 points lower than Green. Teenagers and children can have almost completely neutral whites.
So my making a person's eye whites neutral might be a bit of a cheat. However, like Will, I am sometimes shooting people in the early 20s.
I hope you found this information, including references, helpful.