Ah well, client is king
I think the feeling would remain, but IMO the image would look better... Then again, maybe I've done too many advertising shoots lately: Images cuddled to death
René,
I found it tough to work on these CD covers. It's almost a religious experience for the inititated and outsider have to sense as best the intentions and values of the client. I agree with you that such extreme over-exposures may not be the best way of serving the CD cover's purpose.
However, these bands and groups are small and have often limited finances and following. They struggle and must try to maintain and project their particular image brand. They have to succeed on so many fronts: interesting catchy, edgy lyrics with instrumental backing that draw in and convert the club or venue to their fans and identites.
Photographing Fashion, Weddings, Executive Portraits and Architecture are demanding technically but
easier for the professionals because one
knows the standards one has to meet. Photography for the thousands of singers in groups may seem far easier to do, as the standards are
not so defined. For that reason, it's also hard to be succesful.
Likely that "cuddled images" would not do the work of these "caught in the light" of personal moment" fantasy but "natural" style images Keith has shown.
For example, making the arms symmetrical might convert a cutesy staged setup as if for a Vogue shot. The jewelry would perhaps be for sale!
Keiths shot still has the symbolism, but
vulnerable beauty in disorder.
Most professional photography is about showing things as better than we could find by looking around us. The sections of society that follows the music groups are about identity and fantasy. The fantasy is not getting to perfection, rather perfect disorder and escape from the chains of the larger society and love-life and need for respect and validation.
So bottom line, as a photographer, I'd follow the wishes of the musicians and manager but push as much technical perfection to achieve it as will not damage their intent.
Even for example, her finger nails bother me, however, if they were perfect, likely, the picture would fail. As Keith said, they demanded what he delivered!
Asher