Hi Kathy,
Let's address "focus" and "grainy"
For delivering formal pictures or to emulate and extend the work of great work like that of Ansel Adams, then for sure, these technical aspects or so important, the sine qua non of decent presentation.
Here however, these very same parameters are not important as is whether or not it is projected on the the wall, printed on the side of a truck, rendered in pigment ink or as a C Print. Why the difference and permissiveness?
The answer is related to individual expression and truth as the artist sees it. When, as I imagine the case is here, we are presented with an image clearly signaled as part of or representing fantasy, then the art is what the artist presents.
I'm in synch with your approach to stating your preferences. It's taste that you have issue with. I personally have no big issue with the limited DOF in the first image; the girl
is in focus, just not the grass in the very front.
Asher
I must admit, I would have cheated and replaced the OOF grass!